The only thing I can complain about so far in Washington is the state of athletic programs for children. I am SO frustrated. The programs rely on parent volunteers to coach. None of the programs are requiring those coaches go through any sort of training. Consequently, the experience of the children is more often so negative, they quit playing the sport altogether. Son #1 has dropped out of all sports now except baseball. He is playing fall ball and this is the first season he’s ever played without Steve participating in the coaching at least to some degree, and I fear that he’s very close to being done with baseball too. I am SO tired of these archaic attitudes toward coaching.
There was a T-Ball coach this year that told his team of five year olds, that there was going to be no more FUN, that this was SERIOUS baseball. Are you kidding me?!?! A coach for nine and ten year olds told the kids that they couldn’t do sleepovers when they had games. SERIOUSLY! These kids were in FOURTH GRADE!!!! I realize that when I’m coaching I’m bringing years and years of coaching experience to the table so I have a unique perspective. Coaching was my PROFESSION for 12 years. I have coached kids at all levels, all the way to Olympians. And all I can think of when I hear these idiotic statements from these coaches, is that I’ll bet that those kids will be completely burned out by the time they are 15. I’d bet my house they won’t finish college playing that sport. Because I’ve seen it over and over. When a kid is nationally ranked at eight, they are completely done with their sport by the time they are 18. I know this both as a coach and as an athlete. The dedication and sacrifices that have to be made over and over in the name of the almighty sport, will eventually tear down every single athlete. They wake up one morning and think “I just want to be a normal kid/teenager/college student. I want to be able to do what all the other kids do: watch TV/ go to parties/ lounge around.”
Years ago I coached at a high school and I had a kid who was ranked nationally as a 13/14 year old. By the time he was a senior in high school, he was an all-american swimmer and had accepted a full swimming scholarship to Stanford University, one of the most prestigious swimming colleges in the nation. He had been swimming since he was six. One day, during his freshman year in college, I was still coaching at his high school and he stopped by the pool and said “I really need to talk and I think you’re the only person I can talk to about this.” We sat down and he said “I can’t believe I’m saying this, but I hate swimming. I hate it with all my heart. I just want to be a normal college student and enjoy life and go to parties and do all the stuff the other college freshman are doing, that I can’t do because of swimming. But I’ve got this scholarship and my family won’t even hear of me saying I hate swimming.” My heart almost broke for this kid. He was an extremely dedicated swimmer. He was extraordinarily talented and a coach’s dream. But you could see in his eyes, he was defeated. He was completely burned out. I explored his feelings and motivations with him before coming to the conclusion that he had nothing left to give to swimming. Sadly, I suggested that maybe taking a little break might help him refresh himself. He shook his head. I think he knew what he wanted to say, but was afraid to say it out loud. Finally he did say it. “I want to quit and never go back. What do I do?” I told him he needed to go talk to his coach honestly and tell him everything he had just told me and see what he said. I told him that it was ok with me if he quit. He seemed like he needed permission. He came back to the pool a few days later smiling like I had never seen him smile. He had had that conversation with his coach and his coach told him the same thing I did. It wasn’t worth doing anymore. So he quit. It was a shame too. He could have had a great college career and possibly an Olympic career. This isn’t a unique story. I’ve seen it over and over throughout my coaching career. Part of burn out is perpetuated by the parents. Because within 24 hours of him quitting, his mom was down at the pool screaming at me that I had made him quit and his life was ruined. Parents who are trying to live out an athletic career vicariously through their children will always do more harm than good. Kids don’t need to “get serious” about their sport. They need to do it because they love it. A coach’s job is merely to give the kids the tools and skills they need to be the best that they can be while making sure at the same time they they never lose their love for their sport. What these parent coaches continually fail to understand is that you can make the experience fun and get the most out of the kids without making it seem like work.
For example, I can make kids do sprints. OR I can tell them we’re doing “blue jean relays.” I can offer prizes like candy bars to the winning relay and have these kids work twice as hard as they would if we were just doing sprints. With blue jean relays, they wear their jeans in the pool while doing the sprint relays, which creates an incredible amount of drag. It forces them to really work and serves as a kind of weight training exercise and the kids LOVE it. They think it’s hilarious. And they’re so exhausted by the end of this, they can barely lift themselves out of the pool. But I got 110% out of them instead of 85% and they leave still loving swimming. This type of coaching philosophy is new in the last decade or so. What coaches on the cutting edge of their sports are finding out is that BALANCE is what keeps these kids in the sport. It reduces injuries. It quells burn out. When I was swimming, the philosophy was the more, the better. I could bench press more than my body weight. I swam an average of 10 miles a day. We ran 5 or 6 miles before we even got into the pool, doing hundreds of push ups and sit ups before we got in. What did it get me? Injuries to my back, shoulders and knees. Injuries that I still feel to this day and four surgeries didn’t fix. Career ending injuries.
These old school, hard core, “toughen ‘em up” attitudes are idiotic and destructive. I want to throw up when I see coaches of elementary school aged children allowing only the best kids to play or allowing only the stronger kids to play the better positions. I got news for you, Coach. You’re only as good as your weakest player. Because any team can have a talented kid or two. And those children will thrive under any circumstances, because of you or in spite of you. What proves how well you can coach is how all the other kids are doing. How much improvement your weakest player shows. Any sports fan knows that depth, not the star players are what wins games. And depth only happens if you can build a team. You’re always going to get a child or two that is a coach’s dream. Kids with more talent in their pinky finger than the rest of the kids put together. But if you don’t know how to harness their talent, make them truly love their sport, feed it, and watch it grow, you still failed as a coach. I know many of the old school coaches believe their methods get results. You may still win that trophy, but what did the KIDS gain from the experience? And at what price? Will they still be playing five years down the road? There’s a better way. As a coach, if you don’t care how each and every player on your team is improving and you are only focused on how good you can make that one player, or your child, YOU HAVE FAILED. You’re in it for the wrong, selfish reasons. Get out before you hurt some more kids.
I was talking to one of the Senseis at the dojo the other weekend. I told him how I thought he was absolutely fantastic with the kids. I was so grateful that he was teaching their minds as well as their bodies. He was teaching them life skills and sport at the same time. Son #1 loves karate like he’s never loved another sport and I’m watching him push himself harder than he’s ever pushed himself because he wants to. He wants to work hard for this Sensei and he wants to be as good as he can be. I thanked him. And you know what Sensei said? “My wife is a teacher and we are trying to change the world one child at a time.” So am I, Sensei, so am I.
So I guess you’re wondering where I’m going with this. Sigh. I caved. I am the head coach for son #2’s basketball team. Because I want him to play sports because he loves the sport. And if he doesn’t want to play anymore, I want it to be for the right reasons, not because he had a lousy coach. I’ve finally realized why all these parents were asking me to coach even though I keep insisting I don’t know much about basketball. Coaching is an art. Not just anyone can do it. You may know more about a given sport that I’m coaching, but I can guarantee you that I’ll still get better results. I’ll put my new age coaching philosophy (teach fundamentals, teach the mind, make it fun) up against your old school coaching attitudes any day of the week. You’re only as good as your weakest player, Coach. Remember that.